Our May Tasting


 

Super Premium Red Wines of Chile and Argentina

 
  Paul Watkin
Wine Educator and Consultant
   
 


The Wines We Tasted:
Altos Las Hormigas Malbec Reserva Argentina 2001
Catena Lunluta Vineyard Malbec Argentina 2000
Cadus Malbec Reserva Argentina 1999
Rothschild Escudo Rojo Cab.S./Merlot/Cab.Franc Chile 2000
Antiyal Carmenere/Cab.S./Syrah Chile 1999
Primus Veramonte Carmenere/Cab. S. Chile 1998
Weinert Gran Vino Cab.S./Malbec/Merlot Argentina 1997
Finca Flichman Dedicado Cab.S./ Syrah/Malbec/Merlot Argentina 1997
Concha y Toro Don Melchor Cab.S. Chile 1997
Domus Aurea Cab.S. Chile 1997

 


Our Setting:

Listel Hotel

 
 

 
 

This SWWS event was a privileged opportunity to taste some of the very best wines of South America's two top wine-making countries: Chile and Argentina. All these wines can be picked as a winner on its own and it was hard to compare and vote for our favourite wines as you will see. In addition to these premium wines the Listel Hotel had paired up food to compliment the wines.


Our reception wine was the Tolten Sauvignon Blanc from Chile. This wine is a light style acidic wine with a hint of peach and apricot, and a crisp finish.

Our speaker at this evening's tasting was Paul Watkin, a wine educator and consultant. Paul brings nearly two decades of experience in the wine/hospitality trade. Paul began the evening talking a bit about the wines produced in Chile and Argentina. Malbec he pointed out is the signature grape of Argentina. Also of interest is that Argentina is the fifth largest producer of wine in the world. The problem for us is that most of Argentina's wine is consumed locally. Chile on the other hand has a wider selection of wines in BC, yet is either the ninth or tenth largest wine producer in the World. The Carmenere grape is being more widely known due to Chilean exports. Many of this evenings Chilean wines have some Carmenere.

The wines were tasted in groups. The three Argentinean Malbecs were tasted first and were enjoyed with a grilled vegetable antipasto plate. All three wines were fruity and had hints of chocolate and oak. All three wines were unfiltered, with the Cadus Malbec Reserva having a significant amount of solids left in the glass. The Altos Las Hormigas Malbec left a dark deep purple colour on the glass. It was tart with cherries and dark berry fruits. It went nicely with the sweet grilled carrots. The Catena Lunluta was less intense then the Altos, but was had a more silky mouth feel. It had notes of spice, oak and cherry. The Cadus Malbec Reserva was also deep purple in colour, and had a bouquet with smokiness, pepper and vanilla. The taste was very dry and dusty. It was the most tannic of the three malbecs tasted and also the most full bodied.

The next grouping of wines were the Rothschild Escudo Rojo, the Antiyal, the Primus Veramonte and the Weinert Gran Vino. Each of these wines had a separate food pairing. The Rothschild Escudo Rojo was rated overall as an elegant wine with well integrated tannins and a good length. The bouquet had a hint of green pepper which is a character of Carmenere but was not officially listed as one of the grapes in this blend. Ripe fruit and oak was evident in the bouquet. It was recommended to wait a few years to enjoy this wine at it's peak. The pairing for this wine was the beef tenderloin carpaccio.

The Antiyal 1999 is only it's second vintage, and is an organic wine. It consists primarily of Carmenere with Cabernet Sauvignon and Syrah to complete the wine. It was deep in colour and very opaque. The wine has mineral, currant, cedar, and raspberry aromas and flavours. The Antiyal was paired with lamb sirloin skewers.

The Primus Veramonte was paired with a deli meat platter. It was starting to turn a brickish colour and indicates that this wine is at it's peak. The Primus had a good expression of the Carmenere grape. There was a grassiness, earthiness and smokiness to the bouquet of this wine. The taste was exceedingly smooth, sweet and soft.

The last wine in this group was the Weinert Gran Vino. Smoked chicken in a brie filo purse was the accompanyment to this wine. This wine was described as having a "European" style. The fruit and flavours were not as upfront as the other wines and had some acidity. The taste was soft and smooth with nice fruit flavour.

The last group of wines were the most impressive in quality and this was reflected in their prices, ranging from $35 - $75 a bottle. The Finca Flichman Dedicado, Concha y Toro Don Melchor and the Domus Aurea are all excellent wines. The Finca Flichman Dedicado had a wonderful dark fruit and sweet spice bouquet. The wine had a nice mouth feel, very smooth and silky, with a long finish. This wine was enjoyed with a bleubry and pecan crostinis.

The Concha y Toro Don Melchor is from 100% Cabernet Sauvignon grapes and was aged in French oak for 12 months. It had a leather, minty, and eucalyptus bouquet. The tannins in the wine are quite strong but should soften with aging. The taste was a bit hot from the alcohol content. This wine went very well with the grilled buffalo striploin. It was also very cheese friendly.

The final wine of the evening was the Domus Aurea by Clos Quebrada de Macul. This wine is from the Maipo Valley from 30 year old vines. 1997 is the second vintage of Domus Aurea. It is 100% Cabernet Sauvignon. It has been said that the grapes from this winery are the most expensive in Chile. This is a rich, full-bodied wine witha bouquet of oak, berries and mint. The taste is very smooth. All aspects of this wine are very balanced with a great length. This wine went very well with the soft cheeses and grapes it was paired with.

Tasting Selection
As all the wines were excellent, we could not limit ourselves to a first and second place wine. Our favourite 3 wines for this tasting are:

1. Domus Aurea Cab.S. Chile 1997
2. Finca Flichman Dedicado Cab.S./ Syrah/Malbec/Merlot Arg 1997
3. Antiyal Carmenere/Cab.S./Syrah Chile 1999

 


 

Send us your story

If you have recently travelled to one of the Southern Hemisphere wine countries, then please drop us a note. We'd love to put up a wine travel page .....